Monday, 10 June 2013

Andreas Papandreou Book review

Cold War History recently published my review of Stan Draenos's very interesting book "Andreas Papandreou: The Making of a Greek Democrat and Political Maverick", which also deals with the Greek politician's role in the events that led to the military coup d'etat of  1967 and the imposition of the Greek Colonels' dictatorship.

You can read the review here (free access for 50 viewers).

Cold War History is based in the Cold War Studies Programme at LSE IDEAS, the London School of Economics Centre for International Affairs, Strategy and Diplomacy. It aims to make available the results of recent research on the origins and development of the Cold War and its impact on nations, alliances and regions at various levels of statecraft, as well as in areas such as the military and intelligence, the economy, and social and intellectual developments.

Wednesday, 20 March 2013

Golden Dawn leader statement reminiscent of 1960s Greek military dictatorship

The Greek edition of the daily Kathimerini reports that the leader of the far-right party Golden Dawn, which since last year has 18 MPs in the Greek parliament, said that his movement was born 'as sent from God'.

The statement was made last Friday during an event entitled 'Greek History Lessons - The truth about 1821' that took place in a central Athens hotel conference room. 

According to the same source, Golden Dawn also announced the launch of its very own 'Foundation of Geopolitical and Historical Studies'.

See also a recent, relevant entry on The Economist's Charlemagne blog, here.

The statement is reminiscent of the Greek junta's proclamations in the late 1960s and early 1970s. In particular, the reference to God is strikingly similar to one the Greek ambassador in London made while talking to British Foreign Secretary Brown in late 1967 (see p. 26 of my book on Britain and the Greek Colonels):
'[...] as far as both countries are loyal to NATO and the western
orientation of Greece is one of the basic policies, for which Britain has
fought, the revolution [sic] should be considered by the British Government
as a gift from God’

 Verykios, London to Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA), Athens, 12.09.1967.

Monday, 25 February 2013

Former Greek diplomat on possibility of 1967-style coup

Here's a very interesting article based on an interview with a former Greek diplomat.

According to the the New Statesman, 'Leonidas Chrysanthopoulos was a career diplomat with the Greek foreign ministry. As a junior officer with the service in the 1970s, he helped assure the then freshly democratic nation's accession to the European Union (at the time the EEC). He was at different times Athens' ambassador to Poland, Albania and Canada, and finally the director general of EU Affairs in the ministry.'

Chrysanthopoulos - from 99getsmart.com
Chrysanthopoulos discredited the possibility of a repetition of a military coup (like the one in 1967) in Greece, for the following reason:

There is some good news however that he hears from the contacts he maintains amongst his former colleagues and politicians. He is confident that there will be no military coup, as there was in 1967.
“There are contacts by certain politicians with elements in the armed forces to guarantee that in the event of major social unrest, the army will not intervene.”
“I don't want to go into too much detail here though as it is a delicate issue,” he continues. “But as a result of these contacts, I think this is going to be successful.”

Monday, 18 February 2013

Harold Wilson and Hugh Greene

Today's Daily Telegraph features an interesting opinion article on 'Harold Wilson Night' by the paper's former editor and authorised biographer of Margaret Thatcher, Charles Moore.

Here's an excerpt of the article which refers to Wilson's relationship with BBC Director-General at the time (and head of London-based resistance organisation European Atlantic Action Committee on Greece) Hugh Greene:
http://www.geni.com
No one but the BBC would have dreamt up a “Harold Wilson Night”. It is hard to think of any other politician who was at the top for so long (he won four general elections) with so little to show for it. But it is fitting that the BBC should have commemorated the 50th anniversary of Wilson’s capture of the Labour leadership because, at the time, it loved him.
In the general election of 1964, Wilson spotted that the BBC comedy Steptoe and Son would be broadcast on polling day. Believing that the programme (about father-and-son rag-and-bone men) was particularly popular with Labour voters, and would therefore keep them away from the polling stations, Wilson went to see Hugh Greene, the director-general, to persuade him to reschedule. Greene, who craved a Labour victory, obliged. Since Wilson’s overall majority was only four seats, it is possible that it was the Beeb wot won it.

Saturday, 9 February 2013

ΘΕΜΑΤΑ ΕΛΛΗΝΙΚΗΣ ΙΣΤΟΡΙΑΣ

Αναφορά στο βιβλίο μου από το διαδικτυακό περιοδικό Θέματα Ελληνικής Ιστορίας:

"Britain and the Greek Colonels: Αccommodating the Junta in the Cold War" το νέο βιβλίο του κ. Αλέξανδρου Ναυπλιώτη

Written By φιλίστωρ Ι. Β. Δ. on 20 Ιανουαρίου 2013 | 1/20/2013 04:46:00 μ.μ.

(Σημ Φιλίστωρος: Μια μελέτη από τον κ. Ναυπλιώτη που μοιάζει ιδιαίτερα ενδιαφέρουσα καθώς καταπιάνεται με ένα θέμα που μου φαίνεται πως δεν έχει αναλυθεί επαρκώς ως τώρα στην βιβλιογραφία, ενώ αξιοποιεί μια σειρά από νέα στοιχεία από Βρετανικά και Αμερικανικά έγγραφα που αποχαρακτηρίστηκαν πρόσφατα. Ελπίζουμε να εκδοθεί και στα Ελληνικά το συντομότερο).
Δρ. Αλέξανδρος Ναυπλιώτης*

Στο βιβλίο αυτό ο Αλέξανδρος Ναυπλιώτης εξετάζει τη βρετανική εξωτερική πολιτική απέναντι στην Ελλάδα, αποκαλύπτοντας μια κυρίαρχη αρχή πραγματισμού πάνω απ'όλα. Αυτή είναι η πρώτη συστηματική μελέτη των σχέσεων της Βρετανίας και της χούντας και βασίζεται σε πρόσφατα αποχαρακτηρισμένα βρετανικά και αμερικανικά έγγραφα, καθώς και σε επίσημες ελληνικές πηγές και προσωπικές συνεντεύξεις με πρωταγωνιστές της εποχής. Το βιβλίο είναι μια ολοκληρωμένη ιστορία διεθνούς διπλωματίας και Realpolitik κατά την περίοδο του Ψυχρού Πολέμου. Το παρόν βιβλίο εξετάζει την πολιτική των κυβερνήσεων Ουίλσον και Χηθ ως προς την εγκαθίδρυση και την εδραίωση, αλλά και τις πράξεις της στρατιωτικής δικτατορίας που κατείχε την εξουσία από το 1967 έως το 1974. Επίκεντρο της έρευνας είναι οι διπλωματικές, οικονομικές, πολιτισμικές και αμυντικές σχέσεις των δύο παραδοσιακών συμμάχων. Επιχειρεί επίσης να εξηγήσει τους παράγοντες διαμόρφωσης του «διπλωματικού» χειρισμού της ελληνικής υπόθεσης από τη Βρετανία, εξετάζοντας το γενικό πλαίσιο της «αποποίησης του στάτους παγκόσμιας δύναμης» ως συνέπεια της εγκατάλειψης της «πολιτικής στα Ανατολικά του Σουέζ», και τις σχέσεις των δύο χωρών με τις υπερδυνάμεις και τις περιφερειακές δυνάμεις της εποχής, μέσα στο πλαίσιο του Ψυχρού Πολέμου.
Πιο αναλυτικά, το βιβλίο εξετάζει το κατά πόσον γνώριζε το Λονδίνο για το πραξικόπημα της 21ης Απριλίου, καθώς και το βαθμό τυχόν συμμετοχής του σε αυτό, και αναλύει κριτικά τη βρετανική αντίδραση στα σημαντικότερα γεγονότα που έλαβαν χώρα κατά την επταετία· πρόκειται για σημαίνουσες εσωτερικές εξελίξεις (όπως η πρόοδος της αποκατάστασης της δημοκρατίας), καθώς και για τις προσπάθειες των Συνταγματαρχών για νομιμοποίηση στο εξωτερικό, με κύριο όργανο τη δημιουργία επαφών με κομμουνιστικές βαλκανικές και αφρικανικές χώρες, αλλά και τις συνέπειες της ένταξης της Βρετανίας στην ΕΟΚ.

Αναλύεται επίσης η επίδραση που άσκησαν στις ελληνο-βρετανικές σχέσεις τόσο γεγονότα στη Βρετανία, όπως η οικονομική κατάσταση και οι εθνικές εκλογές του 1970 και του 1974, όσο και διεθνή συμβάντα, όπως η κυπριακή και η αραβο-ισραηλινή διένεξη (οι επιπτώσεις των οποίων διακρίνονται ακόμη και σήμερα), η σοβιετική εισβολή στην Τσεχοσλοβακία, και η διαδικασία της Ύφεσης και της Ευρωπαϊκής ενοποίησης. Ακόμη, η μελέτη αυτή εξετάζει την πολιτική της Βρετανίας απέναντι στη Χούντα σε συνάρτηση με το εξαιρετικά σημαντικό ζήτημα της συμμετοχής της Ελλάδας στο ΝΑΤΟ και τον αντίκτυπο που είχε αυτό στις σχέσεις Βρετανίας και ΗΠΑ.

*Ο Αλέξανδρος Ναυπλιώτης είναι Διδάκτωρ διεθνούς ιστορίας του London School of Economics and Political Science. Έχει διατελέσει Επισκέπτης Ερευνητής στο Ελληνικό Παρατηρητήριο του ίδιου πανεπιστημίου και ερευνητής στη Διεύθυνση Ιστορίας Στρατού, ενώ έχει διδάξει επί σειρά ετών ιστορία διεθνών σχέσεων στο LSE. Άρθρα του έχουν δημοσιευθεί σε γνωστές ακαδημαϊκές επιθεωρήσεις και ιστορικά περιοδικά όπως το European Review of History – Revue européenne d’histoire, το Journal of Modern Greek Studies, το European History Quarterly, το Cold War History, το "Δελτίο του Κέντρου Μικρασιατικών Σπουδών", τα "Ιστορικά Θέματα" και άλλα, και έχει βραβευθεί από την Ελληνική Κοινότητα Λονδίνου για τη διατριβή του με θέμα τις σχέσεις Βρετανίας και Ελλάδας την περίοδο της δικτατορίας των Συνταγματαρχών. 

Σχετικοί υπερσύνδεσμοι:



Book featured on LSE website

My book on Britain and the Greek Colonels' regime is featured on the Main page of the London School of Economics and Political Science under 'New books' by LSE academics.


See more information (including a review by Dr Sotiris Rizas), here.


The book is also featured on the webpage of LSE's International History Department.

Wednesday, 19 December 2012

Publication of the book

The cover of the book
My first book (largely based on my PhD research), on British foreign policy towards Greece in the turbulent late 1960s and early 1970s, has now been published.

Here’s the description of the book:

At the apex of international Cold War tension, an alliance of Greek military leaders seized power in Athens. Seven years of violent political repression followed in Greece, yet, as Cold War allies, the Greek colonels had continued international support – especially from Britain. Why did the Wilson and Heath governments choose to pursue an alliance with these military dictators? Alexandros Nafpliotis’ book examines British foreign policy towards Greece, exposing a guiding principle of pragmatism above all else. This is the first systematic study of Britain and the Junta to be based on newly-released National Archive documents, US and Greek sources and personal interviews with leading actors. Britain and the Greek Colonels is a comprehensive history of international diplomacy and realpolitik in the Cold War period.

You can order the book by visiting the I.B.Tauris website:
http://www.ibtauris.com/

Tuesday, 27 November 2012

Mario Modiano, former Times correspondent in Athens dies

Sad news as former Times correspondent in Athens, Mario Modiano, died at 86.

According to ekathimerini.com:

'Modiano was a well-known chronicler of some of the key moments of Greek history, such as the military dictatorship, the restoration of democracy and the separation of Cyprus'.

He was not loved by the junta because he related in great detail cases of systematic torture of jailed opponents.

You can find an obituary written in The Times, here - and another one, published in the Daily Telegraph, here.

You can read a very interesting interview of his, where he recounts the story of his family's arrival to Greece, as well as his personal experience of the German occupation and the Greek Colonels' regime, here.

A more in depth account of the events immediately after the collapse of the regime can be found in this article he wrote a year ago.

Modiano in Greece - telegraph.co.uk

In this excerpt from my forthcoming book, you can see how Modiano, talking to British officials well before the 1973 Greek republic referendum, predicted, with uncanny precision, the exact percentage of the people who would vote 'Yes' to the constitutional changes.

The fact that both foreign journalists and the British Embassy could so easily provide a accurate estimate of the result well in advance speaks volumes about the genuineness of the referendum.


The last important event of [1973's] ‘pretty gruelling summer’, as far as the domestic scene of Greece was concerned, was the referendum on the amended Greek constitution.


The junta had warned the British that they should not judge the referendum by British standards and members of the international press had expressed the certainty that it would be ‘a farce’. Mario Modiano [...] thought that the decision to abolish the monarchy had been taken a long time ago, told the British that the Colonels would not permit a repeat of the results of the 1968 plebiscite, in order to make them appear genuine: ‘If as seems likely they fudged the figures, they were likely to choose a more plausible percentage (like for example 78%)’ (emphasis added).


This was also the opinion of some FCO officials who had realized, as early as in June 1973, that there was ‘little doubt as to the outcome of the referendum, although the government, who were believed to be embarrassed by the very high yes-votes in 1968, might prefer a rather smaller percentage in their favour this time’.


The British conceded that it was ‘very easy’ to predict the outcome of the referendum, with the Colonels still controlling the levers of power and not being able to afford to lose.

[...] As [British official J F R] Martin admitted shortly before the referendum, ‘few observers doubt that the figure has been decided in advance to within a few per cent’.

Polling took place on 29 July to approve the new republican constitution and the appointment of Papadopoulos as president (reserving for him exclusive powers over defence, foreign affairs and internal security) and Angelis as vice-president.
The final results showed that ‘yes’ got the 78.4% of the vote, which was considered ‘a respectable looking percentage’ in London.
The British embassy’s own estimate had been 78% (emphasis added).







Thursday, 18 October 2012

UK and Human Rights abroad (continued)

Following up on yesterday's blog post on UK and Human Rights abroad, the Financial Times has published an editorial on the subject today, entitled 'Rights in Bahrain'.

The concluding paragraph shows how little things have changed since the 1970s, as Britain was also accused of double standards in its dealings with the Greek dictatorship.

According to the paper,

"The art of foreign relations for any open democracy is to balance defence of human rights with other national interests. Britain has been accused of getting the balance wrong in Bahrain, where repression is a daily presence.

The criticism, made in a parliamentary report, is valid – but only in part. When Bahrain’s government brutally cracked down on anti-regime demonstrators in 2011, leaving 35 dead, the UK was one of the first to protest publicly despite important trade and security links. It is also a behind-the-scenes player in efforts to promote dialogue between the ruling Sunni elite and Shia majority. The US, perhaps with one eye on its naval base in Bahrain, appears to be less involved than in the past, so Britain’s role has become key. Mediators are often more effective if criticism stays behind closed doors.

Nonetheless, parliamentarians are right to say that the UK needs to be more assertive. The softly-softly approach has not delivered results. The difficulty is that the Al Khalifa royal family is itself divided and hardliners have managed to stymie political reform. [...]

Britain, meanwhile, has to be more up front about the conflicts it faces in pursuing national interests. The criteria by which it judges the gravity of human rights failings in ally countries need to be more clearly explained. That is the only way to avoid being accused of double standards."